• Follow
  • Menus
    • Food
    • Drinks
    • Late Night Menu
    • Happy Hour
  • Contact

SMALL PLATES

Something to start out with?

HOT BAKED PRETZEL

HOT BAKED PRETZEL
Choice of savory or sweet sauce $11

homemade Empanada

Homemade Empanada
Choice of chicken or steak, served with tomatillo salsa $7

Hummus & pita

Hummus & Pita
Homemade hummus, warm pita
$13

Guacamole & CHIPS

Guacamole & CHIPS
Homemade guacamole, tortilla chips $13

GRILLED BUFFALO WINGS

GRILLED BUFFALO WINGS
Choice of mild, medium, hot or Thai chili $16

POUTINE

POUTINE
Crispy fries topped with pulled short rib, fontina cheese, and Guinness brown sauce $19

THREE CHEESE QUESADILLA

THREE CHEESE QUESADILLA
Mozzarella, Swiss, cheddar cheese with salsa and sour cream
Add Shrimp 8 | Chicken 7 | Lobster 9 | Steak 10 $12

BRUSSEL SPROUTS

BRUSSEL SPROUTS
Garlic, pancetta, and shaved parmigiano $14

FISH TACOS

FISH TACOS (3 per order)
Cajun Tilapia, lettuce, mango salsa, chipotle mayo, sour cream $20

Shrimp Tacos

FISH TACOS (3 per order)
Coleslaw, avocado, buffalo mayo $24

BAKED NACHOS

BAKED NACHOS
Homemade beef chili, jalapeƱos, cheddar and pepper jack cheese, salsa, sour cream$15

FRIED PICKLES

FRIED PICKLES
Cornbread fried pickle, jalapeƱo jam, house sauce $12

Buffalo Chicken Loaded Tots

Tavern Tots
Monterey jack cheese, ranch, parsley $17

Crispy Sriracha Spring Rolls

Smoked Salmon Wrap
Vegetarian spring rolls served with sriracha aioli $14

SOUP & SALAD

LILLY'S SALAD

LILLY'S SALAD
Mixed greens, cannellini beans, feta cheese, cucumber, cherry tomato, toasted walnuts, black olives, raspberry vinaigrette $16

KALE CAESAR SALAD

KALE CAESAR SALAD
Tossed with a homemade dressing, garlic croutons $15

AVOCADO SALAD

AVOCADO SALAD
Fresh avocado, tomato, black beans, red onions, corn, cilantro, cumin vinaigrette $17

Roasted beet salad

Roasted Beet Salad
baby arugula, roasted asparagus, carrots, red onions, toasted walnuts, avocado, cilantro cumin vinaigrette $17

ADD TO ANY SALAD

Grilled Chicken 7 | Shrimp 10 | Salmon 11 | Steak 10 | Lobster 11

Soup of the day

$9

SLIDERS

Served with side of Hand-Cut Fries (3 per order)

Lilly's SLIDERS

Lilly's SLIDERS
Choice of cheese, served with chipotle mayo$17

BRAISED SHORT RIB

BRAISED SHORT RIB
Fried pickles, caramelized onion$18

Fried Chicken Sliders

Fried Chicken Sliders
Topped with guacamole and mozzarella cheese, with waffle fries $16

Pulled Pork Sliders

Pulled Pork Sliders
BBQ sauce, cole slaw $17

MAC & CHEESE

CLASSIC MAC

CLASSIC MAC
Add Buffalo Chicken 5 | Lobster Truffle 7 | Bacon & Shrimp 7 | Vegetable Confetti 5 $14

BURGERS & SANDWICHES

Served with side of hand-cut fries

Substitute Sweet Potato Fries +2 | Truffle Fries +5 | Cheese Fries +3 | Waffle Fries + 10 | Tater Tots +10

CREATE YOUR OWN

8oz Angus Beef with lettuce, tomato, and red onion $15

BURGER ADD ONS

Pretzel bun, bleu cheese, cheddar, American, Swiss, pepper jack, fontina, mozzarella, roasted mushrooms, avocado, chorizo, jalapeƱo, egg, bacon, fried pickles$2/ea

Lilly's burger

Lilly's Burger
Lettuce, caramelized onions, jalapeƱo, pico de gallo, chipotle mayo $18

COWBOY BURGER

COWBOY BURGER
Grilled bacon and onions, smokey BBQ sauce, cheddar cheese on a toasted brioche bun $19

GRILLED OR CAJUN TURKEY BURGER

GRILLED OR CAJUN TURKEY BURGER
Pepper jack cheese, lettuce, guacamole$17

PAN SEARED BLACK BEAN BURGER

PAN SEARED BLACK BEAN BURGER
Topped with pepper jack cheese$16

Crab Cake Burger

Crab Cake Burger
8oz homemade crab cake, arugula, tomato, and lemon caper aioli served with sweet potato fries$21

Salmon Burger

Crab Cake Burger
Tomato, avocado, greens, tartar sauce, served with waffle fries $25

Lilly's Lamb Burger

Reuben Burger
Tomato, green pepper, cucumber, arugula, bleu cheese, garlic aioli $26

CAJUN CHICKEN BREAST

CAJUN CHICKEN BREAST
Lettuce, tomato, bacon, and cheddar cheese on a toasted baguette $16

Spicy Chicken Sandwich

Spicy Chicken Sandwich
Cornflake breading, cole slaw, pickles, ranch dressing, on a butter toasted brioche bun $16

Chicken gyro

Chicken Gyro
Grilled chicken, hummus, tomato, cucumbers, and garlic aioli on a pita$16

Blackened Sirloin Steak Sandwich

Sirloin Steak Sandwich
Caramelized onions, arugula, Swiss cheese, horseradish cream sauce $22

Smoked Salmon Wrap

Smoked Salmon Wrap
Lilly’s IPA cured smoked salmon, cream cheese, avocado, tomato, red onion, capers, arugula, cucumber, served with sweet potato fries $20

Veggie Wrap

Smoked Salmon Wrap
Lettuce, tomato, roasted red pepper, cucumber, avocado, red onion, balsamic glaze $17

Lobster Rolls

Smoked Salmon Wrap
Three mini rolls served with fries $28

EntrƩes

Teriyaki Salmon

Pan-Seared Salmon
White rice, asparagus $26

14oz Prime Ribeye Steak

14oz Prime Ribeye Steak
Tricolor roasted potato, sauteed broccoli, whole grain mustard and rosemary sauce$34

Linguine Frutti di Mare

Lobster Ravioli
Clams, crabmeat, shrimp, calamari, basil, light marinara $28

Red Snapper Francese

Red Snapper Francese
Tomato risotto, sautƩed string beans $27

Bang Pow Chicken

Roasted Half Chicken
Mashed potato, broccoli $26

Marsala Pork Chop

Honey Garlic Pork Chop
Garlic fried potato fingers, mixed vegetables $29

SHEPHERD'S PIE

SHEPHERD'S PIE
Angus ground beef with green peas and carrots in brown sauce topped with creamy mashed potatoes$22

FISH AND CHIPS

FISH AND CHIPS
Beer battered Icelandic cod and fresh cole slaw served with hand-cut fries $24

Roasted Lamb Shank

FISH AND CHIPS
Fingerling potatoes, roasted vegetables, brown gravy $33

SIDES

HAND CUT FRIES

$8

SWEET POTATO FRIES

$9

TRUFFLE FRIES

$11

SAUTEED KALE OR SPINACH

$9

BRUSSEL SPROUTS

$9

SEASONAL VEGETABLES

$8

MASHED POTATOES

$7
  • Menus
    • Food
    • Drinks
    • Late Night Menu
    • Happy Hour
  • Contact


Happy Hour

Food Menu

Drink Menu



Contact Us

ADDRESS

675b 9th Avenue
New York, NY
10036

Contact

646-490-7329

info@themollypitcher.club

  • Follow

Hours

Monday Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday 5PM–1AM
Thursday 5PM–1AM
Friday 5PM–2AM
Saturday 9AM open
Sunday 9AM open

SEE OUR SISTER LOCATIONS

Boss
Tweeds

Murray St., NY

Visit Website

Get Directions

Lilly's Cocktail
& Wine

Uptown

Visit Website

Get Directions

Lilly's Craft and Kitchen

Hell’s Kitchen

Visit Website

Get Directions

Lilly's of
Long Beach

Long Beach, NY

Visit Website

Get Directions

Monk
McGinn's

TriBeCa

Visit Website

Get Directions

Copyright 2023. All Rights Reserved | The Molly Pitcher Club | Website Design by Aspire Digital Solutions